Skip to main content
Hi! Sign in or registerDaily DealsBrand OutletGift CardsHelp & Contact
Sell
Watchlist
My eBay
  • Summary
  • Recently Viewed
  • Bids/Offers
  • Watchlist
  • Purchase History
  • Buy Again
  • Selling
  • Saved Feed
  • Saved Searches
  • Saved Sellers
  • My Garage
  • Sizes
  • My Collection
  • Messages
  • PSA Vault
Please sign-in to view notifications.
Loading...
eBay Home

Motors

Parts & accessoriesCars & trucksMotorcyclesOther vehicles

Clothing & Accessories

WomenMenHandbagsCollectible Sneakers

Sporting goods

Hunting EquipmentGolf EquipmentOutdoor sportsCycling Equipment

Electronics

Computers, Tablets & Network HardwareCell Phones, Smart Watches & AccessoriesVideo Games & ConsolesCameras & Photo

Business & Industrial

Modular & Pre-Fabricated BuildingsTest, Measurement & Inspection EquipmentHeavy Equipment, Parts & AttachmentsRestaurant & Food Service

Jewelry & Watches

Luxury WatchesWristwatchesFashion JewelryFine Jewelry

Collectibles & Art

Trading CardsCollectiblesCoins & Paper MoneySports Memorabilia

Home & garden

Yard, Garden & Outdoor Living ItemsTools & Workshop EquipmentHome ImprovementKitchen, Dining & Bar Supplies

Other categories

Books, Movies & MusicToys & HobbiesHealth & BeautyBaby Essentials
All BrandsAll CategoriesSeasonal Sales & Events
Advanced
Sponsored
Sponsored

Filter

    • Category

      • All
        • Selected categoryCoins & Paper Money
          • Coins: US
          • Bullion
          • Coins: World
    • Price

      • Under $150.00
      • $150.00 to $350.00
      • Over $350.00
      $
      to
      $
      Please provide a valid price range
      Available inventory
      $0
      $1000+
    • Condition

      • Not Specified (868) Items (868)
    • Buying Format

    • Item Location

      • Within25 mi
    • Shipping and pickup

      • Arrives in 2-4 days
      • Free Shipping
      • Local Pickup within25 miles
    • Show only

      • Free Returns
      • Returns Accepted
      • Authorized Seller
      • Completed Items
      • Sold Items
      • Deals & Savings

868 results for Buffalo ($5, Five Dollar, 10 Dollar) ngc -pcgs -anacs

  • All
  • Auction
  • Buy It Now
  • All Listings- Filter Applied
  • Auction
  • Buy It Now
  • Any Condition- Filter Applied
  • Not Specified
  • Arrives in 2-4 days
  • Free Shipping
  • Best Match
  • Time: ending soonest
  • Time: newly listed
  • Price + Shipping: lowest first
  • Price + Shipping: highest first
  • Distance: nearest first
  • Gallery View
  • Shop on eBay
    Shop on eBay
    Opens in a new window or tab
    Brand New
    $20.00
    or Best Offer
  • Shop on eBay
    Shop on eBay
    Opens in a new window or tab
    Brand New
    $20.00
    or Best Offer
    Sponsored
    • 1938-D 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66
      1938-D 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $79.00
      0 bids · Time left6h 30m left (Today 11:22 AM)
      +$5.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      ravenscoinsandcollectibles99 (54) 100%
    • 1938 D NGC MS67 INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL ORIGINAL BAG FRAGMENT 5C BLACK HOLDER
      1938 D NGC MS67 INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL ORIGINAL BAG FRAGMENT 5C BLACK HOLDER
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $78.00
      7 bids · Time left18h 31m left (Today 11:23 PM)
      +$8.95 delivery
      Located in United States
      thor528 (653) 100%
    • 1937-S 5c Indian Head Buffalo Nickel MS 65 NGC
      1937-S 5c Indian Head Buffalo Nickel MS 65 NGC
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $75.00
      0 bids · Time left2d 18h left (Sat, 10:55 PM)
      +$4.51 delivery
      Located in United States
      qazqaz33 (2,890) 100%
    • 1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C NGC MS65 Key Key Vault Box Series 8 Very PQ! NgcX 9.5
      1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C NGC MS65 Key Key Vault Box Series 8 Very PQ! NgcX 9.5
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $223.72
      7 bids · Time left2d 20h left (Sun, 01:43 AM)
      +$6.40 delivery
      Located in United States
      sergamahoe (832) 99.1%
    • SLAB SEMI KEY 1924-D BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL 5c NGC VF-25 FREE SHIPPING
      SLAB SEMI KEY 1924-D BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL 5c NGC VF-25 FREE SHIPPING
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $105.00
      0 bids · Time left3d 16h left (Sun, 09:49 PM)
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      blarkie (1,634) 100%
    • 1936-D  5C BUFFALO NICKEL  "DENVER MINT"   NGC MS65 #6974242-013
      1936-D 5C BUFFALO NICKEL "DENVER MINT" NGC MS65 #6974242-013
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $75.00
      0 bids · Time left3d 21h left (Mon, 02:11 AM)
      $125.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.71 delivery
      Located in United States
      timothy2005seller (71) 100%
    • 1938-D 5c Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66 Colorful Toning. Our T7079
      1938-D 5c Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66 Colorful Toning. Our T7079
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $130.00
      0 bids · Time left4d 10h left (Mon, 03:51 PM)
      +$5.85 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      djbob6znu (14,542) 99.8%
    • 1913 TYPE 1 UNITED STATES BUFFALO NICKEL 5 CENT COIN GRADED NGC MS65
      1913 TYPE 1 UNITED STATES BUFFALO NICKEL 5 CENT COIN GRADED NGC MS65
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $99.95
      0 bids · Time left4d 15h left (Mon, 08:39 PM)
      +$9.45 delivery
      Located in United States
      oddthings2sell (6,008) 98.6%
    • 1938-D Buffalo Indian Nickel 5c | NGC MS 66 | Denver Mint | Light Gold Toning!
      1938-D Buffalo Indian Nickel 5c | NGC MS 66 | Denver Mint | Light Gold Toning!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $77.99
      0 bids · Time left5d 13h left (Tue, 06:41 PM)
      +$6.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      nicks_coins_collectibles (257) 100%
    • 1928-D 5c Buffalo Nickel NGC MS64
      1928-D 5c Buffalo Nickel NGC MS64
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $154.99
      0 bids · Time left5d 20h left (Wed, 12:54 AM)
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      silverprincess12 (7,859) 100%
    • 1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC Patina
      1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC Patina
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $95.00
      0 bids · Time left5d 22h left (Wed, 03:45 AM)
      +$4.57 delivery
      Located in United States
      ccdickegreen (145) 98.9%
    • 1923-S 5C 🦬 Buffalo Nickel (NGC VF35) LT19602BM
      1923-S 5C 🦬 Buffalo Nickel (NGC VF35) LT19602BM
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $120.00
      0 bids · Time left7d 11h left (07/10, 03:58 PM)
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      adimeadozen (2,855) 100%
    • 1934 5C Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Five Cents - NGC AU 58 Almost Uncirculated 58
      1934 5C Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Five Cents - NGC AU 58 Almost Uncirculated 58
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $79.00
      0 bids · Time left8d 19h left (07/12, 12:18 AM)
      or Best Offer
      +$4.84 delivery
      Located in United States
      man-cave-coins-and-currency (1) 100%
    • :1919-P 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS 64 LOW POP RARITY R3 HIGHEST-GRADES
      :1919-P 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS 64 LOW POP RARITY R3 HIGHEST-GRADES
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $395.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      frankee2004 (3,575) 100%
    • 1925 S Buffalo Nickel NGC VF Details Circulated 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL!
      1925 S Buffalo Nickel NGC VF Details Circulated 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $49.92
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      herbscoinshop (24,034) 100%
    • 1914 s 5c Buffalo Nickel NGC G 6
      1914 s 5c Buffalo Nickel NGC G 6
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $45.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      planetx5613 (4,533) 100%
    • South Africa R5 2023 Silver Proof 1Oz Coin Big5 Series II Buffalo NGC PF69
      South Africa R5 2023 Silver Proof 1Oz Coin Big5 Series II Buffalo NGC PF69
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $299.00
      Buy It Now
      +$15.00 delivery
      Located in China
      yvonneleeshang (562) 100%
    • 1921-S 5c Indian Head Buffalo Nickel - High-Grade Key Date - NGC AU Dets - Y2020
      1921-S 5c Indian Head Buffalo Nickel - High-Grade Key Date - NGC AU Dets - Y2020
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $875.00
      or Best Offer
      +$8.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      the.treasure.source (47,550) 100%
    • 1936-D Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS64
      1936-D Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS64
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $84.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      sarasotararecoingallery (9,208) 100%Visit sarasotararecoingallery eBay Store!
    • 1936-D Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS65
      1936-D Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS65
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $129.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      sarasotararecoingallery (9,208) 100%Visit sarasotararecoingallery eBay Store!
    • 1936-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS65
      1936-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS65
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $129.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      sarasotararecoingallery (9,208) 100%Visit sarasotararecoingallery eBay Store!
    • 1937-S Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS65
      1937-S Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS65
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $78.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      sarasotararecoingallery (9,208) 100%Visit sarasotararecoingallery eBay Store!
    • 1937-S Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS65
      1937-S Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS65
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $78.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      sarasotararecoingallery (9,208) 100%Visit sarasotararecoingallery eBay Store!
    • 1937-S Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS66
      1937-S Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS66
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $118.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      sarasotararecoingallery (9,208) 100%Visit sarasotararecoingallery eBay Store!
    • 1913-D 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC TY1 Early US Type Coin CAC-003
      1913-D 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC TY1 Early US Type Coin CAC-003
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $199.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1913 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 TY1 Early US Type Coin -004
      1913 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 TY1 Early US Type Coin -004
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $350.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1918-D Buffalo Nickel CERTIFIED NGC XF 40  5-Cents
      1918-D Buffalo Nickel CERTIFIED NGC XF 40 5-Cents
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $260.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery in 2-4 days
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      tomscollectibles (45,396) 100%
    • 1913-D 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 TY1 Early US Type Coin -005
      1913-D 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 TY1 Early US Type Coin -005
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $699.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1938-D 5C Buffalo NGC MS66 - Buffalo Nickel
      1938-D 5C Buffalo NGC MS66 - Buffalo Nickel
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $115.50
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      davidlawrencerarecoins (42,371) 99.9%Visit davidlawrencerarecoins eBay Store!
    • 1914 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS65 CAC TONED Early US Type COIN-007
      1914 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS65 CAC TONED Early US Type COIN-007
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $599.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1915-D 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS61 Early US Type COIN-008
      1915-D 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS61 Early US Type COIN-008
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $299.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1931-S 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 CAC Early US Type COIN-009
      1931-S 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 CAC Early US Type COIN-009
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $2,999.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1936-S 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS65 CAC TONED Early US Type COIN-010
      1936-S 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS65 CAC TONED Early US Type COIN-010
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $165.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1937 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 CAC Early US Type COIN-015
      1937 5C INDIAN HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66 CAC Early US Type COIN-015
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $165.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      bluewatercoinsandresale (3,518) 99.5%Visit bluewatercoinsandresale eBay Store!
    • 1937 D 5C Indian Head 3 Legs Buffalo Coin - NGC Fine Details
      1937 D 5C Indian Head 3 Legs Buffalo Coin - NGC Fine Details
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $899.96
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      buyandsell87 (6,571) 100%
    • 1917 5C NGC MS65 - Buffalo Nickel
      1917 5C NGC MS65 - Buffalo Nickel
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $551.25
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      davidlawrencerarecoins (42,371) 99.9%Visit davidlawrencerarecoins eBay Store!
    • 1913 D 5c Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 65 CAC | Uncirculated UNC BU
      1913 D 5c Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 65 CAC | Uncirculated UNC BU
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $439.95
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      jm_gold_and_silver (16,354) 99.8%
    • Gorgeous 1937-S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS 66 5c
      Gorgeous 1937-S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS 66 5c
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $115.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      noobismatic (583) 100%
    • 1938-D  5C BUFFALO NICKEL  BEAUTIFULLY TONED NGC MS64 3423712-007
      1938-D 5C BUFFALO NICKEL BEAUTIFULLY TONED NGC MS64 3423712-007
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $85.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      ace-sirplus (2,608) 100%
    • 1936-D  5C BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66
      1936-D 5C BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS66
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $175.00
      or Best Offer
      +$6.55 delivery
      Located in United States
      may_purchasing (5,071) 100%
    • GEM BU 1938-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS65 NGC Beautiful Coin
      GEM BU 1938-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS65 NGC Beautiful Coin
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $69.99
      or Best Offer
      +$6.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      richesagain (4,049) 99.2%
    • 1936 Buffalo Nickel 5 Cents AU58 NGC
      1936 Buffalo Nickel 5 Cents AU58 NGC
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $41.00
      or Best Offer
      +$4.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      iwillbuyllc (1,055) 100%
    • 1913 S Buffalo Nickel 5 Cent Piece- Type 2, T2, Var 2, NGC Certified, VG Details
      1913 S Buffalo Nickel 5 Cent Piece- Type 2, T2, Var 2, NGC Certified, VG Details
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $288.99
      Buy It Now
      +$3.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      stockmaniac2005 (17,728) 99.8%
    • (5) BUFFALO NICKELS 1913-S Ty2,1915-S,1921-S,1924-S,1926-S *NGC 25-35* FAST SHIP
      (5) BUFFALO NICKELS 1913-S Ty2,1915-S,1921-S,1924-S,1926-S *NGC 25-35* FAST SHIP
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $1,999.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      rarecoins-andmore (2,440) 99%
    • :1920-P 5C INDIAN-HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL SHINY-LUSTROUS NGC-MS-65 R5 HIGHEST-GRADES
      :1920-P 5C INDIAN-HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL SHINY-LUSTROUS NGC-MS-65 R5 HIGHEST-GRADES
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $895.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      frankee2004 (3,575) 100%
    • 2008-W $5 Gold American Buffalo NGC MS70 Early Releases 1/10 Ounce Gold Coin
      2008-W $5 Gold American Buffalo NGC MS70 Early Releases 1/10 Ounce Gold Coin
      Opens in a new window or tab
      1/10 oz · 2008 · American Buffalo
      $939.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      acousha-collectibles (3,473) 99.9%
    • 1915 5¢ Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66 (CAC) Very Sharp Coin!
      1915 5¢ Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66 (CAC) Very Sharp Coin!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $1,150.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      barringerrarecoincurrencybullion (1,279) 100%Visit barringerrarecoincurrencybullion eBay Store!
    • 2021 Cook Islands $5 US State Animal Series Kansas Buffalo NGC MS70
      2021 Cook Islands $5 US State Animal Series Kansas Buffalo NGC MS70
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $75.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.85 delivery
      Located in United States
      grandrapidscoinsllc (10,171) 99.6%
    • 1924 D NGC AU BUFFALO NICKEL ABOUT UNCIRCULATED 5C Coin BUY IT NOW!
      1924 D NGC AU BUFFALO NICKEL ABOUT UNCIRCULATED 5C Coin BUY IT NOW!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $189.01
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      herbscoinshop (24,034) 100%
    • 1935 5¢ Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67  --  Superb Blast White Lustrous Gem
      1935 5¢ Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 -- Superb Blast White Lustrous Gem
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $1,275.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      barringerrarecoincurrencybullion (1,279) 100%Visit barringerrarecoincurrencybullion eBay Store!
    • South Africa 5 Rand, 2021 Big 5 Silver Buffalo, NGC PF69 Ultra Cameo
      South Africa 5 Rand, 2021 Big 5 Silver Buffalo, NGC PF69 Ultra Cameo
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $250.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.85 delivery
      Located in United States
      us_masla (1,632) 100%
    • 1931 S NGC MS9.5 Indian Head Buffalo Nickel 5c Vault Box Series 8 Mint State
      1931 S NGC MS9.5 Indian Head Buffalo Nickel 5c Vault Box Series 8 Mint State
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $499.95
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      silver-eagle-store (82,722) 100%Visit silver-eagle-store eBay Store!
    • 1938 D BUFFALO NICKEL 5 CENT COIN NGC MINT STATE 67
      1938 D BUFFALO NICKEL 5 CENT COIN NGC MINT STATE 67
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $275.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.95 delivery
      Located in United States
      rarecoincollector (46,978) 99.9%
    • 1938-D/D 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS64
      1938-D/D 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS64
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $108.00
      Buy It Now
      +$10.00 delivery
      Located in United States
      leylani1965 (874) 100%
    • 1938 D Buffalo Nickel MS 66 NGC 5c Original Bag Fragment
      1938 D Buffalo Nickel MS 66 NGC 5c Original Bag Fragment
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $125.00
      or Best Offer
      +$4.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      ourfamilysellsonline (337) 99.5%
    • 1926-S US Buffalo Nickel 5c - NGC VF20
      1926-S US Buffalo Nickel 5c - NGC VF20
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $160.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      uskev.fwjxbixig (1,128) 100%
    • 2021 Cook Islands Silver $5 Kansas Buffalo Coin NGC MS70 7K
      2021 Cook Islands Silver $5 Kansas Buffalo Coin NGC MS70 7K
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $99.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      dart66 (5,139) 100%
    • 1938-D 5c Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS 64 Monster Toned
      1938-D 5c Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS 64 Monster Toned
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $148.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      mintproductsdirect (7,017) 99.9%Visit mintproductsdirect eBay Store!
    • 1938 D NGC MS66 Buffalo Nickel 5c US Mint Coin Original Bag Fragment Series
      1938 D NGC MS66 Buffalo Nickel 5c US Mint Coin Original Bag Fragment Series
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $89.95
      or Best Offer
      +$4.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      redlockcoin (20,492) 99.8%Visit redlockcoin eBay Store!
    • 2008-W $5 American Gold Buffalo Proof 1/10 Oz NGC PF70 UCAM
      2008-W $5 American Gold Buffalo Proof 1/10 Oz NGC PF70 UCAM
      Opens in a new window or tab
      1/10 oz · 2008 · American Buffalo
      $1,045.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      altr3010 (710) 100%
    • 1913 Buffalo Nickel 5C Type 1 NGC Vault Box Series 3 MS65 Mint NGCX
      1913 Buffalo Nickel 5C Type 1 NGC Vault Box Series 3 MS65 Mint NGCX
      Opens in a new window or tab
      1913 · NGC · MS 65
      $299.00
      or Best Offer
      Located in United States
      Sponsored
    • 1936-D Buffalo Nickel 5c NGC GEM++ Uncirculated Coin (#6-8647)
      1936-D Buffalo Nickel 5c NGC GEM++ Uncirculated Coin (#6-8647)
      Opens in a new window or tab
      1936 · Uncertified
      $399.49
      or Best Offer
      Located in United States
      Sponsored
    • Tell us what you think- opens in new window or tab
    • Results Pagination - Page 1

      1. 1
      2. 2
      3. 3
      4. 4
      5. 5
      6. 6
      7. 7
      8. 8
      9. 9
      10. 10
      Items Per Page
      • 120Items Per Page
      • 240Items Per Page

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Center
    • Seller Center
    • Policies
    • Affiliates
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2025 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Consumer Health Data, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, CA Privacy Notice, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice
    Copyright © 1995-2025 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Consumer Health Data, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, CA Privacy Notice, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice